Supposedly based on the true story of “the most prolific and unique American serial killer of the 21st century,” Strange Darling dives into the warped, violent and extremely gory mind games of a rampaging psychopath.

Written and directed by JT Mollner (Outlaws & Angels), the film brings a throwback 90s hyper-violent indie vibe, shot entirely on 35mm and presented out of order. Willa Fitzgerald (The Goldfinch, Reacher) stars as “the Lady,” with Kyle Gallner (Smile, Dinner in America) as “the Demon.”

The story kicks off with a young woman, bruised and bloodied up, on the run from a brutal killer. She stumbles upon a house in the woods and seeks help from a startled couple of old hippies played by Ed Begley Jr. (Better Call Saul, A Mighty Wind) and Barbara Hershey (Black Swan, Insidious). The narrative then abruptly cuts ahead two chapters, leaving the audience off balance. From there, we piece together how the Lady and the Demon met, and how their first date spiraled into a nightmarish extended chase scene fueled by drugs, lust, and violence.

It takes a minute to adjust to the out-of-sequence storytelling, and the hyper-vibrant colors reminiscent of a 90s music video, but these choices by Mollner ultimately pay off and play into the frenetic pacing. Is it a little pretentious? Sure, but it also gives the film a distinctive, nostalgic aesthetic that fits the tone like a bloody glove.

Fitzgerald effortlessly transitions from wild party girl to a shrieking damsel – and back again – showcasing her dynamic range and keeping the audience off kilter. Her portrayal of the Lady is both unhinged and mesmerizing.

Gallner’s performance is more nuanced, with subtle flashes of menace that add depth to his character. Their chemistry is palpable, adding further layers to the deranged cat-and-mouse dynamic that drives the story.

Strange Darling is a sick and twisted ride that rewards those who give in to its wild and erratic rhythms. The movie jerks the audience back and forth like a kite caught in a hurricane, and then grabs you by the throat and won’t let go. Buckle up and bring a strong stomach, because this is an unforgettable arthouse thriller.