Duncan Skiles quietly delivered one of the more underrated thrillers in recent memory with his previous film, The Clovehitch Killer, and he returns with another subtle entry into the genre with Neighborhood Watch. Skiles' latest film starts off somewhat unevenly, thrusting viewers immediately into a whirlwind of character dynamics and tense, disconnected situations. Opening scenes involving Jack Quaid’s character awkwardly navigating a diner job application and an abrupt shift to Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s bitter retiree initially create confusion rather than intrigue. It requires patience to settle into the story, but once the narrative finds its footing, the film ultimately rewards viewers' perseverance.

 

At the heart of the film are Jack Quaid and Jeffrey Dean Morgan, who turn in commendable performances as an unlikely investigative duo. Quaid skillfully portrays Simon, a young man burdened by mental health struggles, bringing believable vulnerability and complexity to the role. The film deserves credit for thoughtfully addressing mental illness, never exploiting Simon’s condition for cheap laughs or melodrama. Morgan, meanwhile, is reliably solid as Ed, a retired security guard whose gruff exterior masks deeper emotional scars. Their chemistry becomes a significant driving force, lending credibility to their journey as they navigate their complicated relationship alongside the unfolding mystery.

 

The supporting cast adds additional layers to the story, notably Malin Akerman as Simon's sister, whose grounded performance provides emotional resonance, and a detective character whose pursuit adds a welcome sense of urgency. Though Neighborhood Watch finds its rhythm as the plot progresses, it still lacks the precise execution and gripping tension that elevated Skiles' prior work. The film delivers an engaging enough mystery, punctuated by genuine moments of intrigue and suspense, but occasionally stumbles in pacing and depth, leaving certain emotional beats feeling underdeveloped.

 

While the film doesn't reach the heights of Skiles' The Clovehitch Killer, it comfortably occupies the territory of an enjoyable, if not exceptional, thriller. Sean Farley’s screenplay provides sufficient twists and meaningful character moments to sustain interest without ever fully excelling. Still, there's enough thoughtful character exploration and tension-filled sequences to leave a positive impression, particularly for fans of understated, character-driven thrillers.

 

Ultimately, Neighborhood Watch emerges as a modest thriller, buoyed by strong central performances from Quaid and Morgan and a commendable handling of sensitive themes. Skiles hasn't quite replicated the compelling intensity of his previous work, but he does reaffirm his ability to craft quietly engaging films that fly somewhat under the radar. It may not leave a lasting mark, yet it offers enough intrigue and thoughtful character dynamics to justify giving it a chance.