'Jimmy' Review

Release Date: 11/06/26 [Cinemas]
Genre: Biography. Drama. War.
MPAA: Rated PG13.
Distributor: Fathom Entertainment.
The Verdict: A Maybe

Now 80 years removed from World War II, it feels hard for me to directly relate to how deadly and devastating living through that time must have been. We’re losing more and more of our veterans from that time, so their stories have to be documented secondhand, whether it is in books, movies, or other forms. I also think it is fair to say that American culture has lost much of the unquestioned, unaffected patriotism of that time. There seemed to be real pride in protecting the country back then, mostly because right and wrong were very clearly defined. When comparing our allies to the Nazis, there was simply no contest (we won’t talk about what we did in the Pacific Theater).
Nobody was exempt from the conflict back then. Our most beloved Americans, MLB stars like Joe DiMaggio and Ted Williams, soon-to-be acting superstars like Mel Brooks and Paul Newman, all saw real action and faced the horrors of the war. But there’s something uniquely incredible about Jimmy Stewart’s time in the service. He chose to serve at the height of his celebrity, and he was so effective as a soldier and pilot that he rose to Brigadier General. Jimmy, the new biopic starring Riverdale star KJ Apa as the Hollywood icon, attempts to tell that story. It does a fine job, but it fails to match the extraordinary circumstances.
Jimmy focuses exclusively on Stewart’s life from 1941-1946. Jimmy is the toast of the town. He’s won an Oscar for The Philadelphia Story; he’s dating fellow superstar Ginger Rogers (Jemma Donovan), and his agent, Louis B. Mayer (Jason Alexander), can’t stop the phones from ringing. All of this success makes it a complicated decision when Jimmy’s draft notice arrives in the mail. He is adamant about serving, citing the heroics of his own father (Neal McDonough) in WWI. He convinces Colonel Terrill (Rob Riggle, a former military man himself) to approve his service as a combat pilot in Europe, where he eventually rises through the ranks. The film takes us through his time in that war, the risks he faces, and how he eventually channels the brutality he faced overseas into producing It’s a Wonderful Life, the passion project of his friend and creative collaborator Frank Capra (Max Casella).
Apa’s performance is like a soldier walking through a very active minefield. There is so much risk in imitating Jimmy Stewart’s very famous voice and mannerisms. If you feel it's false even once, the film devolves from drama to unintentional comedy. Apa could’ve been just a step away from those imitators you see outside the Walk of Fame, and it is admittedly impressive that he holds it together. He looks absolutely nothing like Stewart, but he generates enough charisma to play this Hollywood icon credibly.
This film’s marketing did it no favors. The initial trailer for Jimmy made it look like a movie with real cloying sentimentality throughout its runtime. There is some of that feeling in here, but the latter half of the film is basically a PTSD drama, as Stewart struggles to accept the sacrifices his men made on the battlefield as he adjusts back to a life of stardom. That’s an interesting, very specific angle that applies to this man and this man only. Al Pacino never went to war. Brad Pitt was never drafted. I’m assuming that things won’t get to that point for Timothée Chalamet. Stewart’s generation is called the Greatest Generation for this reason.
Having that unique angle for the story doesn't mean Jimmy handles all of this with stunning nuance. Director Aaron Burns seems to have been asked to basically turn the camera on and keep the train on the tracks. There are times when it feels like Jimmy is hokey and corny on purpose, like an homage to the sentimental, all-audience pictures of the 30s and 40s. I felt this intentionality in scenes where gossip columnist Hedda Hopper (Sarah Drew) corners Jimmy for a scoop on his love life, or when Jimmy woos local British widow Gloria (Jen Lilley), who would eventually become his wife. But other times, it feels like the film is laying it on way too thick. Apa is forced to deliver several overwritten speeches to rally his troops, numbing the impact of each subsequent one. And even if this movie is not technically an Angel Studios release, it is very Christian-adjacent, so of course Jimmy needs to carry around his scripture and go to church to ask God for guidance.
Jimmy has many of the classic biopic problems: the story and the character being portrayed are significantly more interesting than the movie itself. Burns attempts to stage some intense dogfight scenes, but budget limitations clearly hamstring any attempt to make those sequences sizzle. The worst case of this movie, an extended 30 Rock cutaway gag, falls flat, and Jimmy doesn’t necessarily make life wonderful for anyone who decides to watch.
Where to Watch:




